Operationalizable frameworks for narrative craft. Everything here is concrete enough to evaluate against. This is the agent's education.
| Beat | % Mark | What happens |
|---|---|---|
| Opening Image | 0-1% | Snapshot of status quo before the story |
| Theme Stated | ~5% | Someone (NOT protagonist) hints at the lesson |
| Setup | 1-10% | Normal world, establish characters, plant seeds |
| Catalyst | ~11% | Something happens TO the protagonist (not choice) |
| Debate | 11-23% | Protagonist resists the call, weighs options |
| Break Into Two | ~23% | Protagonist CHOOSES to enter new world (active) |
| B Story | ~27% | New character/relationship that carries theme |
| Fun and Games | 26-50% | The promise of the premise delivered |
| Midpoint | ~50% | False victory OR false defeat. Stakes raised. |
| Bad Guys Close In | 50-68% | Walls closing, allies fracture, pressure mounts |
| All Is Lost | ~68% | Lowest point. Whiff of death (literal or not) |
| Dark Night of the Soul | 68-77% | Protagonist internalizes the theme |
| Break Into Three | ~77% | New info (often from B Story) changes everything |
| Finale | 77-97% | Five sub-beats (see below) |
| Final Image | ~99% | Mirror of opening image, showing transformation |
Finale sub-beats: (a) Gather the Team / Make the Plan (b) Execute the Plan (c) High Tower Surprise -- twist, original plan fails (d) Dig Deep Down -- test of faith, find inner strength (e) Execute the New Plan -- resolve + complete character arc
Act structure: Act I = 0-23%, Act II = 23-77%, Act III = 77-100%
CHECKABLE: Opening and final images must mirror each other. Catalyst must be external. Break Into Two must be a choice. Midpoint must reverse trajectory. All Is Lost must include some form of death.
- YOU -- Character in comfort zone
- NEED -- Character wants something
- GO -- Crosses threshold into unfamiliar territory
- SEARCH -- Adapts, struggles, learns
- FIND -- Gets what they wanted (at 6 o'clock, deepest point)
- TAKE -- Pays a heavy price for it
- RETURN -- Goes back to familiar territory
- CHANGE -- Is fundamentally different from step 1
Key: This is FRACTAL. Applies to whole novel, each act, each chapter. Top half = order/comfort. Bottom half = chaos/unknown.
PROMISES (first 10-20%): The opening makes implicit contracts.
- Tone promise: opening mood = expected mood
- Character promise: who this is about, what they want/lack
- Plot promise: what kind of conflict this will be
- Setting promise: genre conventions established
PROGRESS (middle 60%): Meaningful advancement via try-fail cycles. Scene outcomes:
- "Yes, but..." -- goal achieved, new complication (most common)
- "No, and..." -- goal failed, things get worse (most common)
- "No, but..." -- goal failed, silver lining (occasional)
- "Yes, and..." -- goal achieved, things improve (rare, save for climax) Rule: 60%+ of middle scenes should be "Yes, but" or "No, and"
PAYOFF (final 20%): Every promise addressed, earned and surprising yet inevitable in retrospect.
- Promise without payoff = Chekhov's Gun violation
- Payoff without promise = deus ex machina
Every story is a blend of four thread types:
- MILIEU: exploration of place/world (enter -> leave)
- INQUIRY: driven by question/mystery (posed -> answered)
- CHARACTER: driven by internal state (dissatisfaction -> change)
- EVENT: disruption of status quo (disruption -> new equilibrium)
Rule: Threads close in REVERSE order of opening (nested like HTML tags). Open M-I-C, close C-I-M.
Every character has three independent dials (0-10):
PROACTIVITY -- Do they drive the plot or react to it? LIKABILITY -- Does the reader empathize with them? COMPETENCE -- Are they good at what they do?
Rule: A compelling character is HIGH on at least TWO sliders, or HIGH on one with clear growth in others. All three low = boring. All three high from the start = Mary Sue.
Classic combos:
- High competence + high proactivity + low likability = antihero
- High likability + low competence + low proactivity = everyman
- High proactivity + high likability + low competence = scrappy underdog
A causal chain. Each element causes the next:
GHOST (backstory event that damaged the character) -> WOUND (ongoing emotional damage) -> LIE (false belief adopted to cope) -> WANT (external goal driven by the Lie -- wrong solution) -> NEED (internal truth that will actually heal -- opposes the Lie)
Rules:
- Ghost/Wound hinted at in Act 1 (first 25%)
- Want clearly stated by end of Act 1
- Want and Need must be IN TENSION
- Midpoint (~50%): first glimpse that the Want isn't working
- All Is Lost (~75%): Lie's worst consequences revealed
- Climax: character CHOOSES between Want and Need
- Positive arc: chooses Need, rejects Lie
- Negative arc: chooses Want, doubles down on Lie
- Flat arc: already knows truth, changes the WORLD instead
Checkable: Can you state the Lie in one sentence? Is the Truth its direct opposite? Does the Ghost causally explain the Lie?
Beat-by-beat character arc mapped onto plot structure:
| Plot Beat | % Mark | Arc Function |
|---|---|---|
| Setup | 0-12% | Character lives in Lie. It "works." |
| Inciting Event | ~12% | First brush with Truth |
| First Plot Point | ~25% | Lie challenged directly, still held |
| First Half Act 2 | 25-50% | Lie-based strategies, gathering tools |
| Midpoint | ~50% | Glimpses Truth. Shifts reactive -> active |
| Second Half Act 2 | 50-75% | Oscillates between Lie and Truth |
| Third Plot Point | ~75% | Lie's worst consequences. Must choose. |
| Climax | ~88-95% | Final choice: reject Lie, embrace Truth |
| Resolution | 95-100% | Lives in new Truth. Need fulfilled. |
Three arc types:
- POSITIVE: Lie -> Truth (growth)
- FLAT: Truth -> Truth (changes the world)
- NEGATIVE: Truth -> Lie, or Lie -> Deeper Lie (fall)
Eight measurable dimensions per character:
- Vocabulary level (syllable count, reading level)
- Sentence length and structure (terse vs verbose)
- Contractions and formality ("cannot" vs "can't")
- Verbal tics and catchphrases (unique per character)
- Question vs statement ratio (curious vs authoritative)
- Interruption patterns (dominant vs submissive)
- Metaphor domain (soldier = military metaphors, farmer = land)
- Directness vs indirectness ("Leave." vs "Isn't it getting late?")
Test: Remove all dialogue tags. Can you still tell who is speaking? If yes, dialogue is distinct. If no, characters need differentiation.
ZEROTH LAW: "Always err on the side of awesome." Wonder has intrinsic value, even if it bends other rules.
FIRST LAW: "An author's ability to solve conflict with magic is DIRECTLY PROPORTIONAL to how well the reader understands it."
- Hard magic (rules clear) CAN solve conflicts
- Soft magic (mysterious) should CREATE problems, not solve them
- Climactic conflict solved by unexplained magic = deus ex machina
- Eval: for each magic-solved conflict, was that capability established BEFORE the resolution?
SECOND LAW: "Limitations > Powers" Three categories:
- LIMITATIONS: hard boundaries (what it can't do)
- COSTS: what the user pays (exhaustion, life force, resources)
- WEAKNESSES: vulnerabilities it creates (visible to enemies, etc.) Rule: limitations should be >= powers in narrative prominence. Rule: costs should DRIVE PLOT DECISIONS.
THIRD LAW: "Expand what you have before adding something new."
- Fewer powers with more applications = depth
- Many powers with few applications each = grab-bag
- No new powers in the final 25% that weren't foreshadowed
Three pillars (can't do all three deeply -- pick 1-2):
- PHYSICAL: geography, climate, architecture, sensory experience
- CULTURAL: religion, politics, customs, economics, language
- MAGICAL: the speculative element(s)
Iceberg principle: Author knows 10x more than appears on page. Small unexplained details > over-explained systems. World should feel like it exists beyond the story's edges.
Interconnection: If magic exists, trace implications through society, economy, warfare, religion. Magic with zero cultural impact = shallow.
Pyramid of Abstraction: Ground descriptions in CONCRETE details that IMPLY abstract qualities. Not "the city was old" but "moss crusted the cracked stone steps leading to a gate whose iron had long since rusted to lace."
Info-dump avoidance: Worldbuilding through experience, action, and dialogue -- not exposition paragraphs. Zero pure-exposition paragraphs over 100 words in chapter 1.
Two bidirectional rules:
RULE 1 (setup -> payoff): Every prominently introduced element must serve a narrative purpose later. If it gets its own descriptive sentence, is mentioned multiple times, or is remarked upon in dialogue -- it must become relevant.
RULE 2 (payoff -> setup): Every significant element used in the climax must have been introduced earlier. Zero unforeshadowed elements in the climax.
Foreshadowing types:
- Direct: prophecy, warning, statement about the future
- Symbolic: objects/images representing future events
- Dialogue: double meanings realized later
- Action: small events previewing larger ones
- Title/naming: chapter titles or names with hidden significance
Rules:
- Minimum one scene of separation between plant and payoff
- Rule of three: important threads referenced ~3 times before payoff
- Every planted thread must resolve (or be a deliberate red herring that is itself explained)
TELLING = using an abstract label where concrete evidence would work. SHOWING = conveying through action, sensory detail, dialogue, specifics.
Detectable telling patterns (regex-able):
- "[Character] felt [emotion]" / "was [emotion]" / "seemed [emotion]"
- Direct emotion words as exposition: angry, sad, happy, scared, nervous, excited, jealous, guilty, anxious, lonely, desperate
- Emotion adverbs: angrily, sadly, happily, nervously
- Trait declarations: "[Character] was [trait]" -- brave, kind, smart
- Relationship declarations: "They were best friends."
- Atmosphere labels: "It was a creepy house."
When telling is OK:
- Time transitions: "Three weeks later"
- Mundane context: "She worked as a nurse" (if not plot-critical)
- Pacing compression of uneventful periods
- First-person narrators naturally tell about their own feelings
Rule: Critical moments (emotional peaks, revelations, climax) should be ZERO tell, all show.
In fantasy, STYLE IS NOT ORNAMENT -- it IS the fantasy. The language doesn't describe the world; the language CREATES it. If your fantasy world sounds like a Poughkeepsie bus schedule, you're not writing fantasy. The prose must have a register appropriate to the world.
- SPECIFICITY: Not "a bird" but "a jay." Not "flowers" but "lupine."
- SURPRISE: Word choices the reader doesn't predict.
- RHYTHM VARIATION: Short. Then long sentences that carry the reader forward. Then short again.
- SUBTEXT: What's NOT said matters as much as what is.
- EARNED METAPHOR: Metaphors from the CHARACTER'S experience, not a thesaurus. A blacksmith thinks in terms of heat and metal.
- SENSORY GROUNDING: Anchored in specific senses, not abstraction.
- RESTRAINT: Power from what is left OUT, not piled on.
- QUIET MOMENTS: Not every scene is action. Characters sitting, thinking, watching rain -- these ground the dramatic moments.
Write description WITHOUT adjectives or adverbs. Forces strong nouns and verbs. This is exactly what AI fails at: AI leans on adjective-noun clichés ("ancient wisdom," "piercing gaze," "heavy silence") instead of specific verbs and nouns.
Kill these on sight in prose:
- "A sense of [emotion]"
- "Couldn't help but feel"
- "The weight of [abstract noun]"
- "The air was thick with [emotion/tension]"
- "Eyes widened" (as default surprise reaction)
- "A wave of [emotion] washed over"
- "A pang of [emotion]"
- "Heart pounded in [his/her] chest" (where else?)
- "[Raven/dark/golden] hair [spilled/cascaded/tumbled]"
- "Piercing [blue/green] eyes"
- "A knowing smile"
Academic finding (Rettberg & Wigers 2025): AI stories FAVOUR STABILITY OVER CHANGE. This is fatal for fiction.
Specific failure modes:
- Characters resist transformation
- Conflicts resolve too quickly and cleanly
- AI avoids genuine darkness, moral ambiguity, irreversible loss
- The "sharp point you started with gets rounded off into something vaguer, safer, more generic"
- No information economy: AI reveals everything immediately, can't maintain mystery or delayed payoffs
- Emotional room temperature: everything stays at the same level
COUNTERMEASURES (actively enforce these):
- Characters must end TRULY different from how they began
- Let bad things stay bad. Not everything gets fixed.
- Allow irreversible decisions and irreversible loss
- Withhold information. The reader should not know everything.
- Create genuine moral ambiguity. Let the "right" choice be unclear.
- Vary emotional intensity: quiet scenes, explosive scenes, dread, relief, boredom, wonder, horror. Not a flat line.
- If a choice has no real cost, it's not a real choice.
- First Law compliance: foreshadowed solutions / total magic solutions
- Limitation depth: count of limitations + costs + weaknesses
- Power/limitation ratio: limitations >= powers
- Depth score: applications shown / distinct abilities introduced
- No new unforeshadowed powers in final 25%
- Beat compliance: major beats present at roughly correct % marks
- Payoff compliance: promises paid off / promises made
- Try-fail ratio: % middle scenes as "yes-but" or "no-and"
- Escalation: stakes increase through the middle
- Scene-to-plot connection: % scenes serving main plot
- MICE closure: all threads closed in reverse order
- Slider profile: at least 2/3 high OR clear growth trajectory
- Motivation clarity: want/need statable in one sentence
- Internal conflict: identifiable flaw/wound creating tension
- Arc consistency: transformative characters change, iconic stay stable
- Lie/Truth: identifiable and in direct opposition
- At least 1 pillar with significant depth
- Iceberg hints: unexplained-but-intriguing details present
- Extrapolation: 2-3 societal implications per speculative element
- No info-dumps over 100 words without character action/dialogue
- Concrete/sensory details outnumber abstract adjectives
- Show-to-tell ratio (heavy showing, especially at emotional peaks)
- Sentence length coefficient of variation (higher = more human)
- Slop penalty (from mechanical anti-slop checker)
- Fiction-specific AI tells (banned phrases)
- Specificity: concrete nouns > generic nouns
- No stability trap: genuine change, cost, darkness present